If you’ve ever stepped into a Wisconsin bakery in early March, you’ve likely caught the scent of something extraordinary wafting through the air—something richer, denser, and more indulgent than your average donut. Meet paczki, the Polish pastries that on Fat Tuesdays are a statewide sensation. But what exactly are these treats, and why do they spark such a frenzy in the Badger State?
Paczki (say it with gusto: “POONCH-kee”) aren’t just donuts with a fancy name. They’re deep-fried orbs of decadence, crafted from a yeast dough packed with eggs, butter, and often a splash of milk or even a nip of grain alcohol. This isn’t lightweight fare—the dough is hefty, designed to hold its shape under a generous filling of fruit jams, custards, or even wild-card flavors like brandy-spiked cream. Once fried to golden perfection, they’re dusted with powdered sugar, glazed, or rolled in granules, sometimes with a hint of orange zest for good measure. Think of them as the heavyweight champions of the pastry world, built to satisfy in a single, glorious bite.
Their roots stretch back to medieval Poland, where resourceful cooks faced a dilemma: Lent was looming, and with it, a 40-day ban on rich ingredients like lard, sugar, and eggs. Rather than let these treasures go to waste, they whipped up paczki as a pre-fasting blowout. The tradition stuck, originally tied to Fat Thursday in Poland, but in America—especially in the eastern half of Wisconsin—it’s Fat Tuesday that gets the paczki treatment. Here, the day before Ash Wednesday transforms into a last-chance feast, a nod to both heritage and hedonism.
So why the obsession in Wisconsin? It’s a tale of culture and community. The state boasts a deep Polish heritage, with waves of immigrants settling in places like Milwaukee, Green Bay, and Stevens Point starting in the 19th century. They brought paczki with them, and over generations, the treat morphed into a Fat Tuesday fixture. Bakeries like National Bakery in Milwaukee, which has been churning out paczki since 1925, or Smurawa’s Country Bakery in Pulaski, where lines snake out the door, don’t just sell pastries—they preserve a legacy. On March 4, 2025, National Bakery expects to crank out 40,000 paczki, while Smurawa’s preps thousands in flavors from prune to peanut butter. It’s not just food; it’s a ritual.
The popularity isn’t only about tradition, though. Paczki have a pull that transcends Polish roots. In Wisconsin, Fat Tuesday becomes a shared party—everyone’s Polish for a day, as bakery owners love to say. The sheer excess of it all helps: these aren’t dainty nibbles. A single paczek can pack hundreds of calories, a sugar-and-fat bomb that screams indulgence. Local twists, like booze-infused fillings at Sweet Perfections in Waukesha or the “wicked game of Tetris” Canfora Bakery plays to fit dozens of varieties into their freezers, keep the hype alive. It’s a culinary event, a race against Lent’s austerity, and a chance to snag a treat that’s gone by Wednesday.
Wisconsin’s paczki mania is more than a sugar rush—it’s a bridge to the past, a community rallying cry, and a darn good excuse to eat something outrageous. So next Fat Tuesday, join the line, grab a paczek (or three), and taste why this Polish gem rules the state’s sweetest day.
We publish a free summary of Wisconsin economic, political and cultural news every weekday morning.
