Critics say new DPI report cards rate failing schools high under revised standards
Wisconsin DPI’s 2025-26 report cards give high marks to 95% of districts, drawing sharp criticism over low student proficiency rates and MPS achievement.
At a glance
- DPI rated 95% of Wisconsin school districts and 85% of public schools as meeting or exceeding expectations, even though recent state test results show roughly half of students statewide are not proficient in reading or math.
- Critics point to lowered proficiency standards and a state weighting formula that shrinks achievement to 5% of a high-poverty school's score—allowing a Milwaukee elementary school with 7% third-grade reading proficiency to earn an "Exceeds Expectations" rating.
- Milwaukee Public Schools celebrated moving up to "Meets Expectations" on a 1.1-point bump, despite ranking in the bottom 0.5% of districts for achievement and posting a 46.2% chronic absenteeism rate.

The Department of Public Instruction released its 2025-26 school and district report cards Tuesday. Critics say the ratings are useless as they hand out good news that student test scores do not back up.
Of the 377 public school districts that received report cards, 358, or 95 percent, met, exceeded or significantly exceeded expectations, DPI said. Of 1,904 scored public schools, 1,626, or 85 percent, did the same. DPI's release said the report cards "show steady academic performance across Wisconsin."
DPI's own test results tell a different story. In October, the department reported that 49.7 percent of public school students in grades 3-11 were proficient or above in English language arts and 50.2 percent in math.
Follow this story every morning.
Get Key Reads, our free daily email: the Wisconsin news that matters, in four minutes or less.
State Sen. Eric Wimberger, R-Gillett, co-chairs the Joint Legislative Audit Committee. He said the ratings look good because Superintendent Jill Underly lowered the bar.
"It's not a coincidence that so many schools in Wisconsin are 'meeting expectations' after Superintendent Underly lowered student success standards," Wimberger said Tuesday. "It's easy to celebrate today's report cards as progress when DPI lowered its own standards of success."
In February 2025, Wimberger and Rep. Robert Wittke, R-Caledonia, announced an audit of how DPI created and applied its new testing standards. Wimberger said the full audit report is expected "in the coming weeks."
The Institute for Reforming Government noted that no district in the state got one star, while 52 percent of scored schools got four or five stars. IRG argues the system also shortchanges schools that serve poor children well. It said DPI denied five stars to several high-performing Milwaukee schools, including Hmong-American Peace, Saint Josaphat Catholic, Saint Augustine Christian, Bruce Guadalupe, Salam Islamic and Saint John's Lutheran.
"We all know DPI has lowered the bar for students. But DPI also does not give high-performing, high-poverty schools the credit they deserve," said Quinton Klabon, IRG's senior research director. "Choosing a school is among the biggest moments in a parent's life, and DPI's report cards do nothing to help them."
The Wisconsin Institute for Law & Liberty went school by school. At Maple Tree Elementary in Milwaukee, just 7 percent of third graders scored proficient in reading on the Forward Exam, yet the school was rated "Exceeds Expectations," WILL Research Director Will Flanders wrote. Statewide, 148 schools had fewer than 20 percent of students proficient in reading. Forty-one of them were still rated "Meets Expectations" or higher.
Flanders traced the problem to how the score is built.
"Growth matters, but a school can post a strong report card score and still have nearly all of their students behind in a subject," Flanders wrote.
DPI pushed back on social media, saying the weighting is set by state law. "The DPI does not 'choose' how report cards are weighted. We apply the weighting requirements established in state law, signed by then-Gov. Walker," the department posted on X.
Flanders answered that the law did not force DPI to lower proficiency standards. "It is possible to create a less-Lake Wobegon report card even under these constraints," he wrote.
MPS takes a victory lap
Milwaukee Public Schools moved up a category this year, to "Meets Expectations." The district sent out a news release headlined "MPS students' academic gains help move district to higher report card category" and said its growth ranks at the 74th percentile among Wisconsin districts.
"Learning to read is a fundamental skill that every student needs to thrive, and our educators deserve real credit for this movement in the right direction," MPS Superintendent Brenda Cassellius said in the release. "At the same time, we cannot be satisfied with a Meets Expectations designation."
The new star rests on a small move. MPS scored 59.5 last year and was rated "Meets Few Expectations," according to DPI's 2024-25 data file. This year it scored 60.6.
Under the state formula, achievement counts for 5 percent of the MPS score and growth counts for 45 percent, according to the district's 2025-26 report card. MPS posted an achievement score of 35.3. The report card says that matched or beat just 0.5 percent of districts in the state.
Here is what the report card shows about MPS students:
- In English language arts, 24.9 percent of tested MPS students scored proficient or advanced. Statewide, 51 percent did.
- In math, 20.3 percent of MPS students scored proficient or advanced, compared with 51.2 percent statewide.
- Nearly 43 percent of MPS students tested at the lowest level, "Developing," in English language arts. Statewide, 18.8 percent did. In math, 51.6 percent of MPS students were at that level, compared with 22.6 percent statewide.
- Twenty-two percent of MPS third graders read at grade level. The state rate is 50.6 percent.
- The district's four-year graduation rate was 72.2 percent, compared with 91.8 percent statewide.
- In 2024-25, 46.2 percent of MPS students were chronically absent, compared with 17.5 percent statewide.
The report card also flags MPS for test participation below the state's 95 percent threshold. In English language arts, 89.6 percent of MPS students took the test.
MPS said 67 of its schools met or beat expectations. Another 74 did not. The district rated 41 schools "Meets Few Expectations" and 33 "Fails to Meet Expectations."
Previously at Dairyland Sentinel:
- Two Audits of DPI Slip to Late Fall; State Won't Say Why
- One Year Later: Dairyland Sentinel, Institute for Reforming Government Press DPI for Transparency on Forward Exam Changes
- WILL Urges DPI to Overhaul School Report Cards for Greater Transparency
- Wisconsin DPI Moves to "Update" School Report Card Ratings Amid Ongoing Transparency Concerns
- Wisconsin Lawmakers Probe DPI Over School Report Cards, Testing Standards
- State school report cards are out, but all is not as it seems
Dairyland Sentinel follows a published Editorial Policy, Ethics Statement and Corrections Policy.
Start tomorrow as Wisconsin’s best-informed reader.
The Wisconsin news that matters, in four minutes or less.
Already a subscriber? Support this reporting with a tax-deductible gift.


