On point. Online. On, Wisconsin.

A Pirate in Wisconsin? Meet “Roaring” Dan Seavey

A Pirate in Wisconsin?  Meet “Roaring” Dan Seavey

On June 11, 1908, a big sailor named Dan Seavey came across the schooner Nellie Johnson tied up at Grand Haven, Mich., with a load of cedar posts. He and a couple of crewmen sailed off with her.

That stunt made “Roaring” Dan Seavey the closest thing the Great Lakes has to a famous pirate. A lot of what gets told about him is legend, and much of it came from the man himself.

From Maine to the Great Lakes

Seavey’s obituary said he was born in Portland, Maine, on March 23, 1865. Research published by the Bethel Historical Society says the year and place are almost certainly wrong and that he was born in Bethel, Maine, around 1869. By his own account, he ran away from home at about 13.

Follow this story every morning.

Get Key Reads, our free daily email: the Wisconsin news that matters, in four minutes or less.

He and his first wife, Mary O. Plumley, had two daughters, born in 1889 and 1890. A 2009 ClassicWisconsin profile, citing the Wisconsin Underwater Archeology Association, places him near Marinette in the late 1880s and later in Milwaukee, where he fished, farmed and ran a saloon.

The rest of his early years depend on whose version you believe. Seavey said he served in the Navy, though no record of it has turned up. He told of selling two saloons and a farm near Milwaukee to buy into an Alaska gold venture that left him broke. One story he skipped: in 1896 he was arrested in Portland, Maine, on counterfeiting charges after a grocer said he tried to pass a fake silver dollar. In 1900 he bought the schooner Wanderer for $600, and he lived on and off in Escanaba, Mich., for the rest of his life.

The Nellie Johnson

The popular telling has Seavey getting the Nellie Johnson’s crew drunk and sailing away while they were out cold. The Bethel Historical Society account is plainer. Seavey took the boat, tried and failed to sell the cargo and stashed the schooner in a river at Frankfort, Mich., where she was later found with six feet of water in her hold.

The Nellie Johnson’s captain, R.J. McCormick, reported her missing. On June 22, he and federal Deputy Marshal Thomas Currier boarded the revenue cutter Tuscarora to go after her. On the afternoon of June 27, the cutter sighted the Wanderer a few miles off Frankfort. Seavey’s crew caught a good breeze, but sail was no match for steam. Newspapers reported that the Tuscarora fired a cannon shot to end the chase. Seavey biographer Richard Boyd checked the cutter’s logbook and found the capture recorded, but no shot.

Front pages from The New York Times to the Chicago Daily News played it as piracy. The actual charge was a lesser one, tied to the fact that Seavey had apparently once been a member of McCormick’s crew, and even that was eventually dropped. For the rest of his life, Seavey maintained he won the boat in a poker game.

Truth and tall tales

Stories credit Seavey with poaching, smuggling, rum-running, stealing cargo from other ships and possibly running gambling and prostitution on the side. Some say he moved navigation lights to run ships aground so he could take their cargo. He was well known as a fighter. How much of it is true is hard to say. Many of the stories come from interviews with Seavey, and others surfaced in newspapers after he died.

One of the stranger claims is that he later went to work for the law. Great Lakes historian Frederick Stonehouse, as cited by ClassicWisconsin, wrote that Seavey was appointed a U.S. marshal to help shut down illegal whisky, venison and smuggling on Lake Michigan. We could not find a federal record that confirms it.

In a 1930 interview, Seavey said he gave up sailing in 1927 after a gasoline explosion on his boat left his right arm paralyzed.

He died Feb. 14, 1949, at a convalescent home in Peshtigo and is buried at Forest Home Cemetery in Marinette.

If you’d like to raise a glass to the old rascal, try a bottle of Roaring Dan’s Rum from Great Lakes Distillery in Milwaukee.

DS Staff

Dairyland Sentinel operates a non profit website and weekday newsletter. Founded in 2023, it is a reader-supported effort. If you'd like to join the staff and cover Wisconsin's cultural, business, government and political beats, email us at info at dairylandsentinel dot com.

More stories by DS Staff →

Dairyland Sentinel follows a published Editorial Policy, Ethics Statement and Corrections Policy.

Key Reads · Free daily email

Start tomorrow as Wisconsin’s best-informed reader.

The Wisconsin news that matters, in four minutes or less.

Already a subscriber? Support this reporting with a tax-deductible gift.

More from Dairyland Sentinel

More History →
Key Reads · The free daily email

Wisconsin’s most informed morning.