Roots
The Wisconsin fish fry is a beloved tradition with deep historical and cultural roots, particularly tied to the state’s religious heritage, immigrant influences, and geographic advantages. Its origins can be traced back to the practices of European Catholic settlers, especially those of German and Polish descent, who arrived in Wisconsin in large numbers during the 19th century. These communities brought with them a religious custom of abstaining from warm-blooded meat on Fridays, a practice rooted in medieval Christian traditions to honor the crucifixion of Jesus on Good Friday. Fish, being cold-blooded, was an acceptable alternative and is not considered meat in the traditional sense. AddWisconsin’s proximity to Lake Michigan and its abundance of freshwater lakes provided a ready supply of species like perch, walleye, and bluegill and a tradition was born.
This religious custom laid the groundwork, but the fish fry as a widespread social tradition gained momentum in the early 20th century, particularly during Prohibition (1920–1933). With alcohol sales banned, taverns across Wisconsin turned to serving inexpensive fried fish dinners to attract customers and stay afloat financially. The plentiful and cheap local fish made this a practical choice, and some establishments reportedly offered free fish with the purchase of a beer—likely served discreetly to skirt the law. This era cemented the connection between fish fries and taverns, blending the Catholic tradition with a growing social ritual that paired fried fish with beer, a nod to the state’s strong German brewing heritage.
The tradition evolved further in the mid-20th century. After World War II, when meat rationing heightened the appeal of fish, and into the 1950s and ’60s, supper clubs—iconic Wisconsin dining establishments—began offering all-you-can-eat or family-style fish fries. This shift broadened the tradition’s reach beyond Catholic communities, making it a statewide Friday night staple for people of all backgrounds.
The relaxation of Catholic meat abstinence rules in 1966, limiting the practice to Lent, didn’t diminish the fish fry’s popularity. By then, it had transcended its religious origins to become a year-round cultural institution, celebrated in taverns, supper clubs, churches, and even fast-food chains like Culver’s. The typical Wisconsin fish fry features beer-battered or breaded fish—commonly cod, perch, walleye, haddock, or bluegill—served with sides like French fries or potato pancakes, coleslaw, rye bread, and condiments such as tartar sauce or lemon wedges. Regional variations reflect local tastes, with smelt fries in spring or catfish near the Mississippi River.
Newcomers Guide to the Wisconsin Fish Fry
A typical Wisconsin fish fry meal is a hearty, comforting spread that reflects the state’s culinary traditions and local preferences. The star of the meal is, of course, the fish—most commonly cod, perch, walleye, haddock, or bluegill. It’s usually prepared either beer-battered or breaded, then fried to a golden crisp. The beer batter, often made with Wisconsin’s own brews, adds a light, flavorful crunch, while breaded versions offer a simpler, slightly less heavy texture. Portions can vary, but many places offer two or three pieces per serving, with all-you-can-eat options popular at supper clubs and taverns.
Accompanying the fish are a handful of classic sides. French fries are a frequent choice, providing a salty, crispy complement to the fish. Alternatively, potato pancakes—sometimes called “latkes” due to Germanic influence—are a beloved option, often served with applesauce for a sweet-savory balance. Coleslaw, creamy and slightly tangy, is another staple, adding a cool, crunchy contrast to the fried components. Rye bread, typically marble rye, is often included with butter, reflecting the state’s German heritage and pairing well with the meal’s richness.
Condiments and extras round out the experience. Tartar sauce, made with mayonnaise, pickles, and sometimes a hint of lemon or dill, is a must for dipping or slathering on the fish. Lemon wedges are also common, offering a bright, fresh squeeze over the fried fillets. In some places, particularly churches or community events, you might find additional sides like baked beans, macaroni salad, or a dinner roll, though these are less universal.
The meal is often served family-style or on a single plate, and in true Wisconsin fashion, it’s frequently paired with a cold beer, an Old Fashioned, or a soda for a non-alcoholic option. During Lent or at certain venues, you might encounter variations like smelt (small, fried fish eaten whole) or even a fish boil (more common in Door County), but the core fried fish-and-sides combo remains the quintessential Wisconsin fish fry meal.
It’s simple, satisfying, and deeply tied to the state’s culture. Everyone is welcome!
We publish a free summary of Wisconsin economic, political and cultural news every weekday morning.
