On point. Online. On, Wisconsin.

Wisconsin School Districts That Face Teacher Retention Challenges Can’t Blame Act 10, Report Finds

Wisconsin School Districts That Face Teacher Retention Challenges Can’t Blame Act 10, Report Finds

The state Department of Public Instruction calls teacher retention the most pressing challenge facing Wisconsin schools. A Badger Institute report says the statewide numbers do not show a crisis, though some districts are losing teachers at record rates.

The report, by Badger Institute policy and legislative associate Wyatt Eichholz, was released Feb. 6, 2025. It draws on 30 years of DPI All-Staff Reports, going back to 1995.

Statewide, teachers are not leaving in droves

Wisconsin had only slightly fewer public school teachers in 2023-24 than in 2009-10, the report found. Enrollment fell over the same period, so the number of teachers per 100 students is the highest it has been in at least 15 years. Teachers are no more likely to leave the profession now than they have been historically, according to the report.

Follow this story every morning.

Get Key Reads, our free daily email: the Wisconsin news that matters, in four minutes or less.

District by district, turnover is up

The picture changes at the district level. Average turnover across Wisconsin’s 414 school districts was higher in 2022-23 and 2023-24 than at any time since 1996. Those district figures count teachers who move to another district, not only those who leave public schools. Statewide totals do not capture that churn.

Act 10

Act 10, the 2011 law that, as the report puts it, “limited collective bargaining to salary,” is often blamed for teacher losses. The report found that the wave of exits in 2011-12, after Act 10, pushed the statewide exit rate from 7.0% to 10.6%. That did not top the historical peak of 11.5%, set in 2003-04. The exit rate climbed to 10.2% in 2022-23, then dipped to 9.5% in 2023-24. Average district turnover spiked in 2012 and has fluctuated between 10% and 15% since.

Who leaves

Exit rates are highest at both ends of the scale. Teachers with the longest tenures and highest salaries have some of the highest turnover rates, most likely because they are closest to retirement, which the report calls unsurprising. On the other end, teachers with little experience and low salaries are the most likely to leave the profession early. The report calls that “a red flag.”

Pinning down the cause is “beyond the scope of this brief,” the report says. It lists possibilities: colleges of education may not be producing graduates ready to teach, schools may not be mentoring new teachers well, students may not be prepared for the realities of the classroom, or pay structures may not give top teachers enough incentive in some districts. The Badger Institute says upcoming analysis will look at those questions.

From a district’s point of view, an open job has to be filled whether the teacher retired or moved down the road. “Competition is healthy and can help create a meritocracy,” the report says, though it adds that shortages in some fields may limit what any district can do.

Read the full report (PDF).

DS Staff

Dairyland Sentinel operates a non profit website and weekday newsletter. Founded in 2023, it is a reader-supported effort. If you'd like to join the staff and cover Wisconsin's cultural, business, government and political beats, email us at info at dairylandsentinel dot com.

More stories by DS Staff →

Dairyland Sentinel follows a published Editorial Policy, Ethics Statement and Corrections Policy.

Key Reads · Free daily email

Start tomorrow as Wisconsin’s best-informed reader.

The Wisconsin news that matters, in four minutes or less.

Already a subscriber? Support this reporting with a tax-deductible gift.

More from Dairyland Sentinel

More News →
Key Reads · The free daily email

Wisconsin’s most informed morning.